Love Island All Stars’ Tom Clare has been slammed for recycling his chat-up lines on new flame Molly Smith this week.

The footballer, 24, joined the stunner, 30, for a cliffside date only for eagle-eyed viewers to spot his romantic declaration was a word for word repeat of what he told ex Samie Elishi, 24, during last year’s series.

Tom and Samie finished in third place in 2023 before splitting upon their return to the UK.

In a now viral clip one viewer posted a side-by-side comparison showing him telling both women as they wore red dressed while on very similar dates: ‘[I] genuinely see you being my girlfriend’.

He went on say how he had ‘tunnel vision’ for only them before dubbing their private time together ‘the best date’ and ‘best first first date’.

+14
View gallery

Love Island All Stars’ Tom Clare has been slammed for recycling his chat-up lines on new flame Molly Smith this week.

The footballer, 24, joined the stunner, 30, for a cliffside date only for eagle-eyed viewers to spot his romantic declaration was a word for word repeat of what he told ex Samie Elishi , 24, during last year’s series (Sam and Tom pictured on the show in 2023)

Taking to X, formerly Twitter, one viewer said:  ‘I knew it, I was like I’ve heard this before’.

While someone else fumed:  ‘I hope Molly sees through this pathetic act’.

As a third commented: ‘This is wild I feel bad for Samie’.

And: ‘Yikes’.

Another typed: ‘Wow how bad is that’.

It comes after it was revealed the show’s iconic heart rate challenge is making a return in Monday night’s All Stars episode.

After Sunday night’s dramatic joint dumping, a teaser video at the end of the episode revealed the islanders will be get risqué to try and raise the most hearts.

The heart rate game sees the Islanders dress up and perform a series of sexy dances to the group of the opposite sex who gather around the fire pit.

+14
View gallery

In a now viral clip one viewer posted a side-by-side comparison showing him telling both women as they wore red dressed while on very similar dates: ‘[I] genuinely see you being my girlfriend’ (Tom and Molly pictured)

+14
View gallery

He went on say how he had ‘tunnel vision’ for only them before dubbing their private time together ‘the best date’ and ‘best first first date’ (Tom and Samie in 2023)

+14
View gallery

Taking to X, formerly Twitter, one viewer said: ‘I knew it, I was like I’ve heard this before’.

But hopeful fans are much more excited to see if the challenge will rekindle exes Molly and Callum’s three-year relationship.

Viewers even went to the extreme of begging producers to ‘rig’ the challenge so that the former couple, who split just last year, will have their hearts raised by each other.

Callum is currently coupled up with Jess Gale, while Molly is happily coupled up with Tom.

Taking to X, formerly known as Twitter, fans continued to root for the duo to get back together, with some joking they have ‘seven more days to make it work’.

Some wrote: ‘THE HEART RATE CHALLENGE HAS ONE JOB- MOLLY CALLUM’

It comes after it was revealed the show’s iconic heart rate challenge is making a return in Monday night’s All Stars episode (Molly pictured)

+14
View gallery

With viewers hopeful  to see if the challenge will rekindle exes Molly and Callum’s three-year relationship (Callum Jones pictured)

‘I REALLY hope the heart rate challenge shows Molly’s and Callum’s true feelings for each other’

‘Heart rate challenge is the best least obvious way the producers can put a spanner in the works! C’mon Callum & Molly, don’t let us down’

‘Oh my god please may Callum’s heart rate be raised the most by molly. PLEASE’

‘I don’t care if producers rig the results. Molly should raise Callum heart rate the most and vice versa’

‘yesssssss HEART RATE CHALLENGE producers have only one job’