The singer, 34, had been innocently enjoying a drink on Sunday night when Koy, 52, made an unexpected quip about her appearances at the tight end’s Kansas City Chiefs games.
He said: ‘Welcome back. As you know, we came on after a football doubleheader. The big difference between the Golden Globes and the NFL – on the Golden Globes fewer camera shots of Taylor Swift.’
The camera then cut to a shot of a stoic Swift sipping on her drink and failing to crack a smile.
‘Taylor nor her girls found Jo Koy’s tacky jab very funny,’ an insider told DailyMail.com exclusively. ‘Clearly neither did the audience and her fans. It made her uncomfortable as it would have anyone.’
Taylor Swift agitated with Golden Globes joke at her expense
+6
View gallery
Taylor Swift chose to ‘bite her tongue’ after Golden Globes host Jo Koy made a ‘tacky jab’ about her relationship with Travis Kelce, a source has revealed
The source continued: ‘At the end of the day his entire performance was the actual joke. He should know who the audience is before coming for them. Taylor just bit her tongue.’
While Swift chose not to respond, the insider teased that her athlete boyfriend, 34, might not be so diplomatic about the moment.
‘She doesn’t have time to clap back at anyone, nor does she want to,’ the source added. ‘She cannot say the same about Travis, who might have some words on his podcast about this.’
The quip immediately sparked backlash from fans who staunchly defended their idol on Twitter.
‘Cause of death for Jo Koy: That look Taylor Swift gave him as she sipped her drink,’ one joked.
Another wrote: ‘Does the fool who’s hosting the Golden Globes and just made a joke about Taylor Swift realize millions of viewers had to Google who the hell is Jo Koy!???’
Others penned: ‘Oh Joe… don’t come for Ms.Swift ! *takes sip*.’
A fourth said: ‘Agree. Uncomfortable laughter. And using Taylor Swift in a joke that stopped being funny months ago was a cheap shot.’
+6
View gallery
The singer looked distinctly unimpressed after she became the butt of one of Golden Globes host Koy’s gags on Sunday night
+6
View gallery
He told the star-studded audience: ‘The big difference between the Golden Globes and the NFL – on the Golden Globes fewer camera shots of Taylor Swift’
But others supported Koy, with one writing: ‘Can Taylor not take a joke? He wasn’t even putting her down it was a diss at the NFL for the way they cover her. It was funny & innocent.’
Koy addressed the reaction at the Billboard after party, telling Extra: ‘It was a compliment, like she could be more intimate tonight, that’s all.’
It was a disappointing night for Swift who lost out to Barbie for the new Cinematic and Box Office Achievement award.
Great Gerwig’s summer blockbuster about the beloved Mattel doll beat out Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, John Wick: Chapter 4, Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning Part 1, Oppenheimer, Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse and The Super Mario Bros. Movie.
Swift was a gracious loser as she led the standing ovation. However her fans were far less forgiving and flooded social media with complaints that she was robbed of a prize, despite claiming it had been ‘invented’ for her.
One tweeted, ‘Golden globes is rigged Taylor should have won,’ while another added: ‘I hope Taylor never goes to these FILM INDUSTRY non-worthy award shows. She is more impactful and popular than everyone in that room combined.’
The camera then cut to a shot of a stoic Swift sipping on her drink as she failed to crack a smile
+6
View gallery
The insider revealed to DailyMail.com that while Swift won’t comment, her boyfriend (pictured left) may choose to clap back on his podcast, New Heights with Jason and Travis Kelce
+6
View gallery
Swift was a style force to be reckoned with in a glittering green gown at the 2024 Golden Globes – which she attended without her boyfriend
A third viewer complained: ‘Taylor was robbed at Golden Globe Awards!!! How can you compare a cartoon movie with a global phenomenon?’
‘Taylor ROBBED,’ another said.
One added: ‘They had to invent a category for Taylor Swift at the Golden Globes and she still lost lmao.’
‘Can’t believe we got robbed of seeing Luke Skywalker presenting Taylor Swift with a Golden Globe,’ one viewer shared.
Another said: ‘Barbie did not deserve the Golden Globe for Cinematic & Box Office Achievement. Taylor deserved that award actually.’
The pop sensation still managed to steal the show in a glittering green gown decked out with countless sequins as she hit the red carpet solo.
She turned up to the glittering Hollywood ceremony without her new boyfriend. It had been expected the pair would not be attending the show together due to his football obligations.