Travis Kelce was absent from Taylor Swift’s big 34th birthday bash on December 13—but that doesn’t necessarily mean his presence wasn’t felt.

In a couple of photos from Swift’s night out at The Box with her famous friends, the pop star can be seen showing off a large ring to Miles Teller and his wife Keleigh Sperry, and fans have reason to believe the bling was a gift from her NFL boyfriend.

Taylor Swift, Keleigh Sperry, and Miles Teller leave The Box in NYC.

A better look.

The statement piece, which can also be seen on Swift’s silver manicured in her Instagram carousel, features a large white stone encased in a ring of blue jewels.

It went perfectly with her sparkling Clio Peppiatt minidress with crescent moon and star details, which she paired with black platform pumps and a glittering silver bag by Aquazzura. The entire look was very Midnights-coded.

Let’s take another peek…

Of course, there’s a reason Swifties think this bling came from Kelce (beyond recent tabloid rumors that the Chiefs player is gearing up to purchase another kind of ring—please listen to “Lavender Haze” again, y’all).

As TikTok user @lesleeey13 pointed out in a video, the ring looks very similar to one that was shared on Instagram by Jay Feder Jewelers in August. You know who follows Jay Feder Jewelers on Instagram? Travis Kelce.

Others suggested the ring may be comprised of opal and blue topaz, representing both Kelce and Swift’s birth stones. “He is an October birthday so the opal makes sense,” one fan wrote, while another commented, “his opal birthstone surrounded by hers.”

Travis Kelce follows @jayfederjewelers as of December 16, 2023.

Despite Swifties’ impressive sleuthing skills, there may be reason to doubt this fan theory. Based on the post’s caption, the rainbow ring seems to be from the Sutra Jewels, a jewelry brand Swift has reportedly worn in the past but is not currently followed by Kelce. Of course, that doesn’t mean he didn’t place the order. Either way, the piece is definitely a conversation starter.