Is Caleb Williams the Next Patrick Mahomes?

Lincoln Riley, the former head coach of Oklahoma and USC, has voiced his admiration for Caleb Williams’ potential but remains cautious about drawing comparisons to NFL star Patrick Mahomes. Riley acknowledges the physical similarities between Williams and Mahomes, recognizing the young quarterback’s elite athleticism and arm talent. However, he stops short of fully endorsing the notion, emphasizing the need for Williams to carve his own path and not be burdened by premature comparisons.

Referring to the buzz surrounding Williams and Mahomes since December 2022, Riley notes the undeniable physical parallels between the two quarterbacks. “There’s some physical comparisons. Like, no question. Both great athletes, both have really elite arms, guys that can throw from all types of different platforms, can really do anything from a throwing perspective that you can imagine,” Riley comments, acknowledging Williams’ potential.

Yet, Riley remains grounded in his assessment, highlighting the disparities in experience between Williams and Mahomes. He points out Mahomes’ extensive collegiate and high school playing time, contrasting it with Williams’ relatively shorter tenure.

“Pat has had a lot more experience than Caleb up to this point. I mean, Pat played a lot of ball in college, Pat didn’t miss a senior year in high school,” Riley explains, highlighting the importance of experience in shaping a quarterback’s development.

Despite recognizing Williams’ physical talents, Riley underscores the challenges ahead for the young quarterback. While Williams may possess similar attributes to Mahomes, Riley emphasizes the importance of Williams forging his own path to success. “To continue to climb to a guy like his level, there’s going to be a big process there. But I certainly wouldn’t put it past him,” Riley remarks, acknowledging Williams’ potential while tempering expectations.

In a sports landscape often characterized by hyperbole and exaggerated claims, Riley’s measured approach offers a refreshing perspective. By emphasizing the need for Williams to develop at his own pace and not be weighed down by premature comparisons, Riley underscores the importance of nurturing young talent in the football world.